Finally something actually happened after they dragged the season for absolutely nothing.
After four mediocre episodes in a row with three of them being filler, this episode is decent enough. Those previous episodes serve no actual purpose other than waiting for the plot to trigger itself by that call.
The dialogues in this episode could be better and so could the way the scenes are cut, especially for the first half. People seem too eager to join The Mando in his quest for the sake of moving the story. However the last 5-10 the minutes is quite watchable with enough tense. The brute killing in the last scene seems to suggest they're going with the "evil Empire" cliche, but I wish they could do better than that next episode.
It seems like the story just started to be set in motion and we will be left with more questions as Season 1 ends, which unfortunately seems to be Disney+ business model: just make cute Baby Yoda stuff for moms and Star Wars reference for dads, figure things out later in Season 2.
On positive notes, it's nice that they attempt to do more world-building like shocktroopers having signature tattoo, each Imperial province having their own insignia, and the Imperial warlord trying to convince people that the world is better with colonialism.
The episode was pretty enjoyable, but...this may have been the worst dialog I've ever heard on television. There wasn't a second of it that flowed naturally. The actors did their best, but you can't spin garbage into gold.
This show is just so frickin GOOD
[8.2/10] Another cool outing for the show. I appreciate that after a few more standalone adventures, the show is mixing it up once more and weaving things back together. Bringing Greef Carga, Cara Dune, Queel the Ugnaught, and IG-11 together for a big confrontation with The Client instantly adds stakes to whatever happens next. Most of these characters haven’t met before, so developing them independently in separate episodes and then having them bounce off one another adds a sense of electricity to the proceedings.
But I also appreciate that there’s a lot of character work, and not just action. That’s primarily for Mando, who wants to find safety for Baby Yoda (something he thinks he can only find if he kills The Client), but also wants to clear his name, because he’s a man of honor and of his world, and so living in exile as a violator of the Guild’s code doesn't sit right with him. He knows that Greef’s invitation is a trap, but he also knows he can’t keep running forever, and this is as good a way to make a stand as any. As taciturn as Mando is, the show does a good job of establishing his motivation.
It’s also an episode about change and choice, which is appropriate for Star Wars. We see two exchanges about droids here, and each has a second layer of meaning for Mando. The first is a narration and montage of Queel reprogramming IG-11, taking him from something designed to murder to something there to help and defend. It’s not something that happens overnight, as Queel describes it and the episode depicts, but something that takes practice, encouragement, and care.
The allegory is obvious but still potent -- Mando himself is learning to be more humane, to be a protector and a caretaker rather than just a dealer of death. The same goes for Mando’s comments to Dune about why he doesn't trust the new IG-11, arguing that its programming can’t be changed and, whether he knows it or not, arguing for why he can’t change either.
But Queel has the best response, namely that a droid is neutral, responding to and reflecting what it’s taught. And that adds the second layer to the metaphor. We’re not just talking about Mando with the metaphor; we’re talking about Baby Yoda. In this episode, we see the little tike exercise two sorts of Force powers. He chokes Cara Dune, a traditional move of Dark Side force-wielders like Darth Vader. But he also heals Greef Karga, a type of force power we’ve never seen on the screen before, which can only be used to help. The implication is that this isn’t just a choice being made for what kind of person Mando will be, but about what kind of example he’s setting for his surrogate son, and what path Baby Yoda will follow.
Beyond that highfalutin stuff, it’s just a good episode on a nuts and bolts level. Mando’s crew has a good dynamic. I particularly appreciate the mistrust between Queel and Dune, given the former’s Imperial service and the latter’s past as a New Republic “dropper.” Queel talking about having earned his freedom after being sold into slavery, a freedom born of the work of his two hands, and Dune’s reluctance to cover her stripes, speak to their characters and gives each depth and texture.
Hell, we even get some shading for Greef here. I’ll be frank -- I assumed he was just going to be a colorful bounty-administering tough and not much more. But the fact that he has a change of heart -- planning to kill Mando and take the kid, only to change his tune when he sees how pure Baby Yoda is and the good he can do -- gives him more depth.
This is also a really well directed and paced episode. Director Deborah Chow does a great job in the pterodactyl attack, having it come out of nowhere and seem like a moment of real chaos. She frames the characters expertly, whether it’s the simple shot depth when we see IG-11’s rehabilitation, or our heroes standing on Durg’s in front of Greef’s hired goons. Granted, it’s a little tough to discern what happens in the final sequence where Mando (I think?) shoots The Client, but for the most part, this is a visually superb outing, whether or not there’s action going on.
And hey, we get one more Werner Herzog monologue out of the deal! His comments about prosperity under Imperial rule and chaos and death reigning in the aftermath of the Rebel victory are intriguing, and add some “a good villain believes what they’re doing is right” shading to the baddie. A lot of the dialogue here is very mannered, very dramatic, but the episode strikes the right solemn tone through most of this and that make it work.
That solemnity goes a long way toward the episode’s ending which is, in movie terms, where our heroes have reached their lowest point. The mercenary types are pinned down by an Imperial battalion. Baby Yoda is in the clutches of a speeder bike trooper. And poor Queel is dead, having worked so long for his freedom (three human lifetimes), to earn a life of self-reliance and quiet, only to die in service of a fight that wasn’t his, that he joined from his sense of honor. It is tragic, in the best way, and makes things that much more charged, that much more powerful, as we head into the finale.
WTF!!!! There's no way they killed Kuiil!!!
This is honestly so sad, I hope they're misleading us into thinking he's dead, I hope he's still alive.. Such a great character, we don't want to lose him
This episode overall was stressful and great for the plot at the same time, we now might have some surface idea on why they want baby Yoda.. Before I thought it was to harness his force powers but now I think it has to do with his healing ability
Anyway the show has been great so far, we have 1 more episode to go for the end of this season
This episode had me glued at the screen. It's a huge homage to Sam Peckinpah's films, and clearly sets the mood for a great season finale. This is what really makes Star Wars great: it made deeply care for the characters and I felt despair with every single loss and setback they experience. And the ending... Oh, my gosh. It broke my heart. This is going to be a very long week until the next episode!.
After a few stand alone episodes the plot-line finally reappears and it's glorious. Thrilling, I was captivated from beginning to cliffhanger end. Only bad thing about it dropping on Wednesday this week is having to wait all that more longer for the next one.
Just as things seem to be coming full circle by bringing back different characters, this episode ends with one hell of a cliffhanger. The loss of Kuiil off screen and Baby Yoda's capture was quite the twist. The season finale will definitely bring about more on Baby Yoda's past and what Moff Gideon plans to use the child for. (Perfect timing as The Rise of Skywalker comes out this week to keep Star Wars fans satisfied.)
Incredibly good episode. Exciting story, great characters and locations. Also I loved the new TIE-Fighter and to see more of what became of the Empire after the fall.
IG-11, Scout-and Death-Trooper yay. The rest? Boring af.
Only Four Storm Troopers. .
.
haha
I thought pain was watching the elf’s two dinosaurs being killed by dragons but then I knew real pain after what happened to Kuill, like WHY???
And I’m really confused cause this is after the 70s trilogy so Leia, Luke and Han defeated Darth Vader and the Empire, so why does no one know about the force???? And that Darth Vader wanted the force or whatever and that he fought the jedis??? Does the general population don’t know who Yoda is??? How do people and aliens don’t know that? What do they think the whole Empire thing was about?
Why in the hell did they waste so much screen time telling the story of how the damn battle droid became a household droid? It had better come back to save the baby yoda looking thing. Otherwise, I can't emphasize enough how useless of a rant that was. Also, I'm disappointed to not see the ground defenses on that spaceship. Maybe next episode.
Crappy cliffhanger ending. Cheap Hollywood lazy nonsense.
What an incredible episode! and you can see the force healing in this episode which was also present in TROS.
the finale is going to be insane!!
I was starting to like Hoggle! :(
Be my mother, Gina Carano.
I like cliffhangers, but this one was painful. Loved the episode, but now I'm just aching :P. Luckily going to see The Rise of Skywalker saturday, to ease the suffering a bit :D This show needs fricking 13 Seasons!
So they finally start connecting the dots. It doesn't make the last episodes any better but it gives them at least some perspective and meaning. Althought I am sure there could have been another approach. Not complaing though. I still think this will end on an even bigger cliffhanger and we won't learn who, or what, the Littly Guy (and until proven otherwise I won't call him anything else) really represents. He is the incentive for viewers to keep watching
"Droids are not good or bad. They are neutral reflections of those who imprint them." This is a great line from an episode that recontextualizes a lot of what The Mandalorian as a show seems to be trying to do. In the best parts of the episode, the show explores the idea of nature vs. nuture, and whether or not one's "programming" can be inherently changed. This is probably why Kuiil walks away as the best character of this first season by a landslide - he's exactly the kind of grounding The Mando needs in order to work as a character.
Even outside of all of that, Deborah Chow is a wonder of a director here, bringing her propulsive, forward momentum to an episode that is all setup, and yet pay offs in a wonderfully climatic way. The final shots here are a hell of a cliffhanger, some of the best of the show, and the stage is set for an action packed finale. Stellar stuff.
The Mandalorian is the greatest SciFi series to release since Battlestar and Caprica. Opening up the Star Wars universe with a new lens to bring back some older story elements with a continued story. The true continuation of the Star Wars legacy.
9/10
Superb
"Precious creature
I can see why you
don't want yo harm
a hair on it's wrinkled
little head" lol,lol
Best statement of the
season hahaha.
Great to see my girl
Cara Dune back and
having Mandos back,
4 storm troopers lol
I loved how she kept
that running through
the entire episode,
That was so funny.
When I heard the deal
at the beginning of the
episode I was like yeah
what could go
possibly wrong,
I just glad Mando wasn't
alone and he had two
friends he could trust
with his life and baby
Yoda's life.
Ready for this
Season finale time for
a rescue mission mi thinks.
This episode is an improvement in comparison to the previous one, maybe because we revisit old characters and learn a bit more of their backstory. Mandalorian's ex-employer contacts him and offers him a deal which will enable him both to keep the baby and have his name cleared in the guild. Apparently his territory was overrun by some post-empire warlord, which is bad for business, and Mandalorian's role would be to kill the said warlord, using the baby as bait (this is supposed to be the client from the beginning of the show). Mandalorian sets out to find his allies, and these are the warrior woman Cara and the man he helped him during the action to get the baby. There is a short conflict between them at the beginning as he had apparently been forced to join the empire's army, while she served the rebels. The man shows himself to be a clever inventor and programmer, apparently he found the robot Mandalorian "killed" when he found the baby, and reprogrammed it so that it is now a friendly droid serving tea. This does bring some subtle "Doctor Who" references to the Daleks in the episode with Winston Churchill, where the Daleks do the same thing. Further on in the episode, there is a kind of Tolkien reference as the characters go through wastes which resemble Mordor, with rivers of lava, and when they camp there at night, they are attacked by creatures that bring to mind the fell beasts of the Nazgul, though I guess they have their own names and roles in the world of Star Wars. There is more action from the baby as he shows his magic powers again (I guess this is called the Force in the Star Wars universe, but functionally it is just the same as magic, isn't it?), first by almost choking Cara when she has a fist-fight with Mandalorian, and later by healing Mandalorian's ex-boss when he is bitten by the Nazgul. So the baby is apparently adept in both killing and healing. Then there is a change of the plan, when Mandalorian comes up with the idea that the ex-boss and the warrior woman would pretend to have captured him, whereas the friendly man is to take the baby back to the space ship. When they meet the client, everything goes south and they are attacked by an army of Stormtroopers and other imperial soldiers - possibly? The baby is captured by the Stormtroopers and the man Kuill seems to be killed; though as I have recently discovered, there is a high survival rate among deceased Star Wars characters so let's hope it would be the case with Kuill as well since he is a likeable character. I am not sure about the ending as it looks like the ex-boss of Mandalorian turned out to be the mastermind behind the attack? as the person who gets out of the plan looks quite like him. I was thinking that maybe the baby would do something to the pursuing Stormtroopers as he is not so helpless as he looks like, but apparently nothing of this sort happened. It seems he only uses his magic when he believed that Mandalorian is threatened.
I have a few qualms with how this season has been panning out, but only one episode has been purely uninteresting for me. I don't really like how much this show is relying on multiple seasons because I think it stilts the storytelling a little. And I don't mean with the episodic approach, I mean with how that episodic approach only retroactively became more filler-esque now that we have more meat on the bones with an overarching plot.
To be completely clear: I don't think television needs to go for overarching narratives. It operated for nearly forty years without really doing them and you'd be hard pressed to find shows better than some of the early fare (I Love Lucy or The Twilight Zone). And I don't even feel that three of the four episodic pieces of this season are that bad. Perhaps a bit of an expectation adjustment, sure, but only Sanctuary felt tired. That was mostly just because of the tropes it rested on being so tired.
It's interesting to see a show like this during peak TV because of how it plays with its narrative structure. The idea that we do actually deal with the elephant in the room in this episode and (presumably) the following sort of makes up for the slow start. I don't know that I expected to be this on board with this show, but the past couple episodes have pushed a lot of narrative tension--even though the previous episode was still episodic--that makes the experience have a lot of intrigue. It's incredibly watchable.
Now, as far as how this compares when placed in the larger Star Wars cannon I think is even more interesting, because as far as I'm concerned The Mandalorian feels most similar to Solo. And I'm fascinated by the polar opposite reception these two pieces have because they really operate all that differently. I personally though Solo was pretty superb, but I know I have a minority opinion. Mic dropped.
We meet up with Mando who is going back to Nevarro after getting a message from Greef Karga that the empire has takevn over the empire and he can clear his name if he helps him remove the empire from there and so Mando teams up with Cara Dune and Kuill ("i have spoken" guy) and then they do return and what awaits them on the other side is something..this series is building up to a big climax and the ending ahh...it was emotional thats for sure.
I HAVE SPOKEN ! One of the best episode of the show
Finally! A good episode! Gosh, I enjoyed this one, the previous one established how dangerous he could be. This one takes you back to the story of the first two episodes and makes some progress with it. Honestly, for what, 8 episodes? I thought they could have fleshed out the main story a bit more, this feels very episodic. Oh wait...
Now that's a good one, about time
Well this felt as good as the first few chapters, i wish the season finale is better
A return to form after two lackluster episodes. This was easily on the level of the first three episodes of the season.
Not much I can say, except I'm now incredibly excited for the finale.
This episode was good but it still has a downside to it.
Overall I liked it, especially when Mando formed his crew.
Shout by Gloom8BlockedParent2019-12-18T17:16:52Z
Funny thing is, if the last episode was only about uniting allies (before the landing on the Guild planet or whatever it's called) it would have been nearly perfect like first 4 episodes. I wish they wouldn't rush the first part it's generally felt great with clashing histories and what not. The series suffers the moment you think about alternative routes or how many plot conveniences happens in any given episode. But alas, ending scene carried some serious weight and there were a couple of enjoyable character's moments (among see through plot twists and a bit of bad acting...) any who it feels miles better than the last one so hooray they did it again (close enough)!
Btw, how many days exactly passed after he killed the droid? Cause the story demanded some passage of time to feel powerful and I couldn't stop thinking how at best only a single month passed)