All Comments about...

The Island 2005

One of the best from Michael Bay. Since it's not all about explosions and is a pretty good movies about clones.

loading replies

Great first half of the reveals were fantastic. But the second half seemed like one big chase scene that I found very uninteresting. Then I saw it was a Michael bay film and it all made sense. It would have been better as a black mirror episode or maybe just shorter.

loading replies

Concept vehicles, concept future world, concept cloning. Watched it for ScarJo and I was happy.

loading replies

I really enjoyed this, it had a unique premise that was predicable but not completely ridiculous.

loading replies

I used to love this movie as a kid. Will definitely not rewatch it, I want to avoid its flaws. Still, it was my sci-fi. I was addicted.

loading replies

Very good movie - much better than expected. Plenty of action and enough twists to keep you interested.
The ending is somewhat predictable - what Hollywood movie isn't?
9/10

loading replies

In case your thinking of watching this DON'T it sucked

loading replies

Action movie with very promising first 30 minutes (this could have been a REALLY great movie!) but after that it turns into a typical and boring "Michael-Bay-Crash-BOOOM-BANG action flick"!

loading replies

Finally I'd climb out of a plot hole but then immediately fall into another one. I experienced that the entire film

loading replies

This starts off like such a unique and great concept, then Michael Bay takes charge. It goes on for too long and the last hour is basically a giant chase/action scene. There is a much better 100 minute runtime version that doesn’t have the Michael Bay stamp. Still solid, just could have been great.

Rating: 3/5 - 75% - Worth Watching

loading replies

This was an awesome creepy futuristic sci fi movie, which honestly wouldn’t be too far fetch from our near future.

loading replies

Ok so I don't claim to be scientifically inclined and correct me if I'm talking out of my ass here...but if the primary motivation for cloning is to harvest organs, why not just clone only the organs? Surely if they have the medical technology needed to clone entire human beings they can simply clone want they need? I would think it save costs as well as avoid at least some of the ethical dilemma.

loading replies

Brilliant first hour - great plot concept, well executed, good pacing. Then Bay can't help but ruin it...

Choppy fast paced edits are one thing. Two CGI stunt sequences that would embarrass a Roger Moore Bond film are another... Totally unnecessary and they ruin the movie really.

It's an enjoyable watch. It could have been much, much more.

The story works as an allegory to life in general. The concept also doesn't seem overly far-fetched given where science is in this area - and the lengths the rich will go to.

6.5/10

loading replies

Not many movies are saved by the story until about the middle. Just yikes. Bay's directing style gives me headaches.

loading replies

The conception of this film has a great potential, and Bay ruins it as much as he can. Instead of focusing on the moral questions this topic could bring up, or focusing on the characters who could be much more interesting and are portrayed by legendary actors like McGregor and Buscemi, Mr. Bay decides to do his usual predictable action-scene montage and that TERRIBLY UGLY color grading. Also, this film has one of the lamest endings I have ever seen. It is just lame. They were already at 1 hour 40 minutes when they realized they should wrap the plot up as quick as they could to fit into the 2-hour limit. Could have been a masterpiece. I'm so sorry Bay directed it.

loading replies

I love the idea behind it but I expected more from it especially in the end.

loading replies

I used to consider this one of Michael Bay's "good ones." Upon rewatch I don't think thats the case. It's not the worst but I can't sit here and say it's good. So that means according to my count/personal taste, Bay has two good ones to his name, The Rock and Pain and Gain.

loading replies

Decent.
The huge action scene in the middle was unnecessary and boring.
The ending felt wasted.

loading replies

Largely pointless. There's a chase sequence where I just want the heroes to smash into a building and bring everything to a merciful ending.

loading replies

Shout by Deleted
BlockedParentSpoilers2017-10-17T16:25:46Z

I freaking loathe this film. At first is kinda catching but then is sooo boring and the storyline for me, it's totally uninteresting. They were clones! Nobody cares about them as long as their owners (the real people) are fine. 3/10

loading replies
6

Shout by Deleted

The concept was good and a more cerebral approach could have yielded a really good movie. The emphasis on action detracted from the concept and we ended up with something that's an OK watch, but ultimately a bit disappointing.

loading replies

So apparently they get their manicure done in there
and you mean to tell me that all these people who still believe the whole contamination thing (they are potentially dangerous but they hadn't started asking any questions yet) just run into the world without a single worry in the world?
and why are they wearing white in the end in the boat scene? if i were them i probably wouldn't wear white ever again
At least we got that great acting by ewan mcgregor

loading replies

Michael Bay's hysterically silly take on Logan's Run. Relentlessly frenetic, but it still manages to be boring.

loading replies
Loading...