This was interesting but... I feel there has to be more to it than "it was Clara." I mean, who wrote that word on the board? Who said "Listen" outside the time ship? And, most importantly, who was that under the sheet?? Depending on what happens over the rest of the season this could either be Moffat at his best (e.g. A Good Man Goes To War, where all the tiny hints and pieces suddenly fit together perfectly to form an amazing whole) or at his worst (e.g. The Girl in the Fireplace, where the premise looks clever and everything is loaded with emotion, but once you think about it for more than one second there's gaping plot holes that totally undercut the emotional impact of the story). As a standalone, it's not as bad as the latter but certainly nowhere near as good as the former.
Shout by CluisannaBlockedParentSpoilers2019-02-10T23:26:55Z
This was interesting but... I feel there has to be more to it than "it was Clara." I mean, who wrote that word on the board? Who said "Listen" outside the time ship? And, most importantly, who was that under the sheet??
Depending on what happens over the rest of the season this could either be Moffat at his best (e.g. A Good Man Goes To War, where all the tiny hints and pieces suddenly fit together perfectly to form an amazing whole) or at his worst (e.g. The Girl in the Fireplace, where the premise looks clever and everything is loaded with emotion, but once you think about it for more than one second there's gaping plot holes that totally undercut the emotional impact of the story). As a standalone, it's not as bad as the latter but certainly nowhere near as good as the former.