[7.5/10] The big question for any legacy sequel/revival is simple -- does it feel enough like the original? And the answer for X-Men ‘97” is...sort of!
The animation is weird, man. Sometimes, it’s tremendous. The sequence where our heroes plummet from the sky amid a Sentinel attack, replete with last minute rescues and an eye-blast landing from Cyclops, is kinetic and thrilling as all hell. The throwdown with Master Mold and his coterie of malevolent automatons gets the blood pumping with all sorts of cool X-Men powers on display. And there are plenty of “This makes no sense, but it’s made of awesome, so it gets a pass” moments like Beast controlling one of the bots from the inside. In terms of raw octane, the animators get it done.
But hoo boy, the character animation is all over the place. Sometimes the X-Men have an expressiveness that outstrips the original show, and sometimes they feel like bizarre stiff corpses who are being electrified at random intervals. Jubilee and Sunspot’s dance is particularly jarring with the strangeness of their movements. Quiet scenes often veer into the uncanny with a strange combination of the under-animated and over-animated parts of the show that can either wow you or repel you from moment to moment.
The truth is that the powers that be were always going to have to update the animation, if only to go to a widescreen format. And despite sporting some iconic designs (which have been suitably updated), the original X-Men animated series wasn’t necessarily the peak of animation either. But this is certainly different, and not always in a good way.
The same goes for the voices and the pacing. Many of the original voice actors have passed on. The ones who remain have obviously aged in the (gulp) three decades since X-Men originally ran. Their replacements vary in quality. Ray Chase does a remarkable job replicating the original Cyclops. Jennifer Hale is an outstanding voice actress, but doesn’t necessarily sound much like her predecessor. Cal Dodd, Lenore Zann, and George Buza are all a bit off as Wolverine, Rogue, and Beast respectively, which makes sense given changes in voices and performance styles in the last thirty years. But Alison Sealy-Smith’s Storm hasn’t missed a beat.
Meanwhile JP Karliak’s Morph and A.J. LoCascio’s Gambit are able replacements for the originals, despite other new voices not quite hitting the mark. And despite playing a character who's new to the series, the actor who plays Sunspot is flat and unconvincing to the point that you wonder how the performance made it in a professional production. But the voice acting in the original show wasn’t always sterling, so hopefully things improve from here.
Likewise, “To Me, My X-Men” occasionally feels like a bunch of scenes slapped together rather than a cohesive story that builds and ties everything together. Again, that was sometimes an issue with the original show, so I can't fault its 97 equivalent too much for that. But the pacing is different, both in individual scenes and the episode as a whole. It’s hard to pin down, but there’s a certain anime vibe to the presentation, a different style and approach, that stands out relative to the 90s predecessor.
And yet, despite my gripes about the craft and the presentation, I appreciate the threads that “To Me, My X-Men” picks up. One of the long-running threads of the prior series was Scott Summers wrestling with what it means to be the X-Men, and even how it would feel to do the job in Xavier’s absence. Picking that back up, having him torn between walking in Professor X’s shoes versus leaving the X-Mansion to raise his child(!) with Jean, is a strong emotional throughline for the episode that connects with past events well.
Well, more or less. Look, it’s been more than a quarter century for most viewers. The creative team understandably wants to catch viewers up. So there’s a certain sense of “Hey, here’s everybody’s deal!” to the episode. Wolverine’s still sweet on Jean and snippy with Scott. Rogue’s still plagued by her inability to make contact with others, but has a certain amiable concordance with Gambit despite that. Beast still dispenses literary quotations with ease, and Jubilee still laments not getting to the fly the jet. If you haven't done a rewatch, or lived on the memes, there’s plenty here to introduce the characters and their dynamic.
I especially appreciate the re-addition of Morph, who was one of my favorite characters from the original series, and who adds to the team dynamic in the current one. His shapeshifting powers are a nice way to invoke everyone from Archangel to Blob to Professor X himself without having to actually include those characters. And his shit-stirring personality remains intact. Likewise, Bishop doesn’t do much beyond join the fray, but it’s nice to have such a frequent collaborator be a part of the regular team as well.
Granted, there’s a lot of exposition here. You kind of expect that, given the gap in time between seasons, so to speak. And it’s nice for the show to pick things up with Gyrich and Trask and the Friends of Humanity and the Sentinels, even if it involves a lot of “As you know”-type dialogue to get lapsed viewers back up to speed. You can pretty readily see the seams of this being a relaunch, with all the table-setting and throat clearing that entails.
All of that said, I appreciate the ways “To Me, My X-men” parallels the first episode of the 1992 series with some suitable twists and new wrinkles. We return to a conflict between the X-Men and the sentinels. They face down the same villains. They solve the same sort of mystery. They face the same sort of prejudices they did before.
Only this time, Cyclops is in charge and having to figure out how to balance principle and practicality. This time, they’re already a family that must be held together, rather than recalcitrant individuals who need to come together. And most movingly, now it’s Jubilee who’s helping to take in a lost soul struggling with their powers, speaking to what the X-Men did for her and her self-esteem when they took her in amid the prior series’ premiere. That's a nice way to mark how far Jubilee has come (in a better fashion than the original show’s Xmas special), and to start things anew in the same spirit, with her as an ambassador for what Xavier’s School for the Gifted can do for someone.
X-Men ‘97 seems to carry on that spirit. I can't pretend it gets everything right. Some of the changes are jarring, or downright strange. But this feels enough like the X-Men I knew and loved growing up. It pushes the right nostalgia buttons, while taking a few risks to move things forward and recognize the changes that have taken place, in television and society, in the last thirty years. Given the strife and prejudice of the day, the X-Men are more salient than ever, and being more than a mere tribute, X-Men ‘97 seems to recognize that. The angles aren’t always clean and the seams sometimes show, but in its opening hour at least, “To Me, My X-Men” is a quality retrofit, ready for new purpose.
I need to go back and rewatch the original now. This new series looks good and getting off to a nice start.
I grew up watching the original but this felt a bit corny.
The animation looks worse than what it was 30 years ago. There's no fluidity in the movements.
And what's with the cinematic aspect ratio? So dumb...
I've only just recently watched the original series (in fact I just finished the last two episodes last night), so that's very fresh in my mind and this first episode is a pretty good continuation. The story feels true to the major themes that the original series dealt with, as well as continuing pretty much exactly where they left off.
Plus the fight/action scenes were just incredible, particularly Cyclops in the FOH warehouse, Cyclops using his powers to slow his descent, Storm single-handedly taking down an entire group of Sentinels and the creative use of Gambit, Wolverine and Morph to tag team takedown Master Mold, all genuinely exciting stuff.
Speaking of Morph, it's quite ridiculous for people to get riled up about the character being non-binary now. It's not even directly, if at all, mentioned in this episode and it makes sense for a character who can look like anyone to not conform to a gender binary, especially a character who has dealt with the struggle of understanding where they fit in throughout the original series and isn't that what the X-Men have always been about anyway?
The only thing that really stood out to me in terms of flaws was some of the returning voice cast are showing their age, in particular Rogue and Wolverine. Not a whole lot they can do about that, but when the rest of the cast are doing such a good job, it's easier for something to stand out that might otherwise slip by largely unnoticed.
All in all I enjoyed this episode, and if it's a sign of what's to come I think this series could easily stand alongside the best of the original series.
X-Men was one of my favorites when I was young, and it was hard to catch all the episodes on Fox Saturday mornings. Eventually, many years later, I was able to watch the complete series in order on Disney Plus.
Now, X-Men '97 is back, and wow, it's like I'm 20 years old again. They pick up right after the end of the series, with the X-Men prepared for a change after the death of Professor X, and man, does this show still have that '90s vibe to it, and I appreciate that. It's not a reboot but a continuation.
It was great seeing Trask and Master Mold; however, they were taken down a bit too easily, but I understand they wanted to move the plot along. I am so happy they are returning the anti-mutant themes of the first season, which I felt was always the strongest of the series. Wolverine is back to his mopey self, pining over Jean. Cyclops is a ballbuster. All the characters are spot on.
The first episode is mostly setting the stage and the stakes. I felt this episode did a good job of that, and I'm looking forward to where things are going. Obviously, Cyclops and Jean's baby will be the focal point, but this is a Saturday morning kids' cartoon at its heart, so I'm going in expecting writing of the sort. And that's exactly what I want.
Still down with getting that nostalgic rush every time the theme song plays.
Cyclops intro was so damn good. Love how he used his blaster to maneuver around. That was new for me. Then to follow it up with that landing with no parachute was the icing on the cake.
Come on! What's not to like? The animation is very good! The character design is beautiful! The vibe of 97 is there, but it feels modern. The use of each character's powers and abilities is great! It started very well! I hope it keeps surprising us!
I hope this is helpful! Let me know if you have any other questions.
Wow, color me impressed! After watching the whole original series, experiencing the huge downfall it took, and the rumors that this show was gonna follow along the MCU woke tradition, I was worried for this. Luckly, thus far, this had me completely surprised in the best way possible! They actually ditched the silliness and childhood vibe of the original show and seem to be actually following the vibe of the 90s comics! Even adapting aspects that the original show ditched! And the animation is amazing, down to the perfection of the new intro!
If this keeps up it is gonna be the best Marvel Studios project in years!
This revival is just perfect it genuinely feels like just a new season of the OG show (but with better animation)
The animation seems like it's missing a few frames at times. Also, the quality overall looks a bit blurry, I'm not sure how that's even possible.
The original Xmen might look a bit more flat color wise, but it seemed smoother to me.
Full disclosure I'm biased! Xmen has always been my favorite Marvel team. I've missed this show from when I was young.
Initially, I thought I wouldn't appreciate the modern twist to the old graphics. I would rather it be completely new with the more modern look. However, it didn't bother me much as the upgrade is still a lot better.
Cyclops was never my favorite. However, the way he is done in this show, I'm having second thoughts as to his ranking, in my opinion.
I've watched it multiple times already. Can't wait for the next episodes.
Real crap compared to what the other series were. How did they manage to make the graphics and movements worse than the older versions ♂ Give it to disney if you want to make a shit version
It's a shame they didn't make a sequel to X-Men evolution, which was this X-Men cartoon that I watched when I was a kid
Rogue's VA is my favourite VA from the og show, but sadly.. she didn't sound great in this episode. She's just too old for the role.
I wish they added another classic X-Men character to the team instead of Bishop. He should be used occasionally like in the og show, to show up when some time travel shenanigans are happening. Also, changing his long hair look is a travesty.
Teared up when Magneto showed up at the perfect moment
Happy nation sounds positively haunting in that rendition.
Kudos, they kept themes, values and characters all intakt. This series always felt ahead of it's time... and product of it's time. So, X-men being corny is actually spot-on thing. Honestly feels like seamless transition, to how I remember X-men at least, including plot continuation.
I only wish my child self would remember what happened to Charles exactly. I think he was somehow trapped inside Jean's mind... maybe kid's drawings are hint to Jean's childhood? So, maybe Phoenix is in the cards, heh. I like slight adjustment with FOH treatment.
I never watched the og show but the hype got to me for this one/ and my god this fucking amazing. From the character dynamics to the action and the overarching mysteries being woven together everything about this episode had me hooked. Its just a genuinely brilliant pilot to what's shaping up to be a brilliant show
While I never watched the OG 90s cartoon I am very familiar with the x-men in their original comics and in adaptation (snaps to X-Men Evolution) X-Men '97 even in this brief 30s minutes has already captured exactly what I love about this superhero found family.
Nostalgic. Amazing. Great Cyclops is front and center. Let's work baby Summers' whole story Arc into the new series.
I've only (recently) seen first 4 eps of the original series... this does seem like a true continuation (except for Morph's pronouns, and I think we're cool with that so long as nobody's demanding we say ours).
Its ok start for me will see how they continue the show
Scott Summers = the worst character
Loved it. Well done first episode. Significantly better than What If?
I love the fact that they brought this show back!!! This episode was so on point too!! Great animation and excellent fight scenes that gave me everything the old show had with a modern day feel to it. Voices seem the same too.
Shout by SpiderJerusalemInTheMountainsVIP 2BlockedParent2024-03-20T16:46:45Z
Happy to recognize some voices, and after checking, the original voice actors are back for Storm, Wolverine, Rogue, Beast and Nightcrawler!
Side Bonus: I learned that the actors who voice Beast and Nightcrawler were both in X-Men Last Stand.
That said, I found this too much like the comic series Claremont restarted, and I really didn't enjoy it; that said, I could be over nostalgic for my rating, I am not sure yet, but it did feel good to see.