Marshall and Lily's costumes look great.
Had a great laugh, rewatching this episode, and letting the brain make connections.
Barney shows up as Maverick, from Top Gun, while Ted is looking for Slutty Pumpkin
Seasons later, Ted meets Slutty Pumpkin - while is played by Katie Holmes
Shout by SmatthewVIP 7BlockedParent2020-03-30T05:34:05Z
Cute episode. Marshall and Lily looked adorable together. Marshall pulled off the gay pirate look, ;)