Season 5

Scott Aukerman

Self - Host

20 episodes

'Weird Al' Yankovic

Self - Co-Host

20 episodes

Mary Sohn

Mary

2 episodes

Paul F. Tompkins

Alan Thicke (voice) (uncredited), Lord Andrew Lloyd Webber

2 episodes

Kevin Bacon

Self

1 episode

Tony Hale

Self

1 episode

Tegan Quin

Self

1 episode

Sara Quin

Self

1 episode

T-Pain

Self

1 episode

Aubrey Plaza

Self

1 episode

Joe Jonas

Self

1 episode

Nathan Fielder

Self

1 episode

Kristen Schaal

Self

1 episode

Paul Rust

Self

1 episode

Chris Wood

Perry Daffodil

1 episode

Lou Wilson

Cashier

1 episode

Mike Colter

Self

1 episode

Grant Palmer

Leland

1 episode

Rowan Smyth

Young Boy

1 episode

Bil Dwyer

Captain Brock

1 episode

Kaley Cuoco

Self

1 episode

Krysten Ritter

Self

1 episode

Zach Galifianakis

Self

1 episode

Tim Heidecker

Phil Gorsley

1 episode

Andy Samberg

Self

1 episode

Gillian Jacobs

Self

1 episode

Jorma Taccone

Self

1 episode

Akiva Schaffer

Self

1 episode

Ben Folds

Self

1 episode

Jason Mantzoukas

Self

1 episode

Allison Janney

Self

1 episode

Nick Kroll

Fabrice Fabrice

1 episode

Ronnie Adrian

Ronnie

1 episode

Malin Åkerman

Self

1 episode

Regan Burns

Wilford

1 episode

Timothy Casto

Denny

1 episode

Ingrid Haas

Propmaster Diana

1 episode

Ashleigh Crystal Hairston

Ashleigh

1 episode

Joel Jensen

Self

1 episode

Laraine Newman

Mandy

1 episode

Haley Joel Osment

Slow Joey

1 episode

Chris Parnell

Poseidon

1 episode

Bryan Safi

Freddy

1 episode