The show is good. My only complaint is that guy who plays Usopp. He can't act for the life of him
This was a slog to get through. I don't know why they decided to give early One Piece's weakest villains a two-parter, not to mention that they're even cringier in live action. Whoooo, cat pirates, scary!
All I could think of while watching this episode was, SMILE! ANYBODY, PLEASE FOR THE LOVE OF GOD SMILE OR LAUGH OR DO ANYTHING BUT BROOD! This ain't Mr. Robot, guys, it's a funny pirate show!
Kaya got more character development than Usopp in his own arc, isn't that crazy? I suspect it's because they realized Usopp's actor can't... well, act too good. Very unfortunate because now Usopp barely feels like a character at all, and gone is his pigheadedness and selflessness that makes him a worthy member of the Strawhats. He's basically just been hanging out all this time and watching the other Strawhats hog his character-establishing moments.
I agree with another comment, Nami is saving this for me.
We finally get We Are!
Not putting Jango and his moonwalk in this episode is a frickin' travesty.
Also, the acting in Zoro's past was uhh.. something. My God, Kuina's actress coming in hot with a perfomance straight out of The Room. The child actor for Luffy is Al Pacino for all of them.
Look, in my opinion, they did their best to add intensity and tension to what was admittedly a goofy arc in the original. I mean, cat pirates. Sheesh. I also liked the relationship between Usopp and Kaya a lot more here. I've always liked them, but the live-action adaptation could go places the original couldn't, and I enjoyed that. I was also glad to see we left Kuina's death as an "accident," leaving out the "died by falling down the stairs." Still, I wouldn't say I like this background story, but it's a little less grating like this.
Overall, I think they did a good job. It's VERY different from the original, but I don't think the original would've worked with the tone changes they've done, you know? Anyway, I am not at all attached to the original arc, so I'm fine with that, lol
Coming from a watcher of the anime series;
Enjoying this a lot so far, definitely a pretty good live action adaptation!
The fight was so intense! Looking forward to more.
Klahadore's not bad. But his movements just look ridiculous.
Zorro's fights are much better than Luffy's. Too bad he spends half the episode pitifully trying to get out of what looks like the easiest to climb well I've ever seen in any movie. Was it really the time for a pick me up flashback ?
Usopp doesn't appear half as useless and annoying than in the manga.
Maybe it would have been hard to pack the whole story in one episode, but two was too long.
Some would think, a fast moving pirate with knifes on his fingers cold chop everyone up into little pieces rather easily, in this case quickly.
This was with no doubt the weakest episode so far, and I think the issue this time is mostly the script. Coby’s involvement in the plot is so weird and honestly he might have not been there and it wouldn’t change anything, Zorro’s backstory felt shoe-horned in since it doesn’t connect to any character moment of his, the fight with Kuro was anticlimactic and ended too quickly. It just felt messy and I’m unsatisfied. The next episodes are more important and I hope they nail them.
They played the song! It's structurally a little wonky with an odd choice of placement for Zoro's backstory, and I think they're playing Usopp just a hair too straight, but it's another blast of an episode with great action, soaring adventure, more than their money's worth in bladed gloves, and a great cliffhanger twist.
(853-word review) As the climax of the previous episode, this one was bound to surpass it, which it easily achieved, to no one's surprise, especially myself. It was understandably better and more exciting. Alexander Maniatis stepped up his acting even more, giving Kuro a fiercer presence and deeper depth, albeit in the category of capricious and extravagant villains, and there were two fight sequences/action, making up for the prior lack of that element.
Luffy vs. Kuro was undoubtedly the best because (one.) we get to see Kuro receive his comeuppance at (two.) the hands (and head) of Luffy, and (three.) a glimpse of a serious attitude, more than when he nearly lost his hat two episodes ago, which unsurprisingly stemmed from his crew/friends being in danger; that grin while pulling Kuro's arms away from each other was peak cinema – Luffy's a complete menace.
Zoro vs. Sham (whose actress is undeniably hot, especially as the character; her actual (pirate) outfit also looked great) and Buchi was a little weaker but still decent; it was even more riveting in some ways, thanks to the execution of the choreography, which was good, with Mackenyu being the highlight, as he's trained, in addition to that fight sequence serving as a moment for Zoro to shine. But, under the surface, some parts of it revolving around Sham and Buchi, relating to their characterizations, were silly, and the choreography itself would've benefited immensely from a tiny amount of improvement: their characters knocked it down a notch.
However, from what I've seen, those who disliked the first installment of this two-parter also felt similarly regarding this episode. I can't quite put myself in their shoes to comprehend where they're coming from, at least concerning its entirety. But there were two points that I agreed with, which were mentioned by some and likely felt by the majority of individuals who weren't fans of these two episodes.
Here are those points: Sham and Buchi were extremely underwhelming (but perhaps it's the same in the manga: there wasn't much that could be done to elevate their characters in live-action), and their quirky, argumentative dynamic was dull and awkward, whether the cause was the performances by Bianca Oosthuizen and Albert Pretorius or that those types of characterizations usually don't turn out well, particularly in live-action media, while Audrey Cymone's (Shimotsuki Kuina) acting was noticeably weak, following that same reality with Colton Osorio (Young Luffy) and Kevin Saula (Young Usopp), specifically the latter; however, Maximilian Lee Piazza's acting as the younger version of Zoro was better, not to mention there's still the young versions of Nami and Sanji to judge, who could end up being the best ones out of those actors.
Besides that, I'm going against the grain concerning how it seems the other way around for many people: this episode was better than the previous one. The final 10-12 minutes, or so, in particular, once the Syrup Village Arc concluded, were fantastic. But overall, there were many things to like, starting with the score cues; Sonya Belousova and Giona Ostinelli popped off.
These were the most notable ones: the one during Zoro and Kuina's fight, especially the energetic end of it as their battle concluded, the one when Zoro found out about her death/took her sword/as he was climbing up the well – the flute was excellent or whatever instrument that was; I've heard it before, and I know it's used frequently in Japanese or maybe Chinese music, and that score cue felt both reminiscent of their work on the first season of The Witcher and reminiscent of the music in Naruto/Naruto Shippuden (the climax, while Zoro made it up, was particularly fantastic); the one when the crew gets the ship (that middle part of the "I'm Gonna Be King Of The Pirates / We Are!" track is phenomenal), and the one when they sailed off, including the montage of everyone and how they're settling in, which could be that same track but a different part, and it sounded even more like the score in S1 of The Witcher.
The remaining things were specific scenes: Luffy throwing up on Helmeppo and his reaction, Helmeppo's look of resignation at Zoro's appearance, knowing he's about to get bullied again, then getting knocked out – his character, who's more so the butt of the joke (but lowkey HIM) has been a treat and portrayed fabulously by Aidan Scott; Zoro's backstory was excellent, not to mention the primary highlight of the episode; Luffy smiling at Nami after he won the bet of getting a ship; the scene at the end of the crew where Nami laughed, then Zoro followed was great – "This is what it's all about" is the truth! Thank you for saying it, Luffy! And we love it!
Honorable mentions: Celeste Loots (Kaya) gave a stand-out acting performance, going even further than initially, following in the footsteps of Alexander Maniatis. She was an unexpected highlight of these two episodes in that department. And the cinematography, most notably the lighting/sunlight and beauty of the ocean, looked incredible. Real locations and natural lighting win every time.
I am solely watching it out of curiosity and the hype. Haven't read one-piecce. This show is one of many examples as to why live-action adaptations often lack the charisma of comics or animations- I'm sure the anime version of this show is far better. The actors failed to pull me in except kaya, nami, kuro, marine captain, and both marine cadets. The show tries to be serious at times and then fails spectacularly at it. Buggy had been the most interesting villain so far.
It could be a fun silly show if they didnt try (and fail) to be serious.
Edward Scissor Hands, that was different and fun. :thumbsup_tone1:
Unsure how non one piece (manga/anime) fans are enjoying this but nami and zoro make the show watchable. The other actors are very boring. But one thing is that usopp was very annoying when he was first introduced, they nailed the annoying part in the live series but also added very poorly acted! I will continue to watch, only really for nami
Shout by Efrén RodzBlockedParent2023-09-03T04:22:47Z
I loved the backstory of Zoro so much! I got the feelings even in those quick flashbacks, awesome :heart: